"I'm delighted to be on the list of Banned Books. To think that I am in the company of Mark Twain, the Bible, and other giants of literature is mind blowing. What an esteemed group.
I don't know why "Julie of the Wolves" was banned, but the critics seem to be fussing about Daniel's pushing his wife, Julie, to the floor and tearing her dress. They call it "rape" because they didn't read it correctly. Daniel ran outdoors saying, "I can,"(surprise) -- that is, he is able another day to claim Julie as his wife -- so Julie, who is afraid of him, leaves. I had to have an urgent reason to have an Eskimo girl run away, as the Eskimos are very home and family oriented. Since "My Side of the Mountain" was criticized for not motivating Sam, I motivated Julie.
And thereafter lies her tale of revealing the intelligence and behavioral traits of wolves."
My Thoughts: This was one of my favorite books when I was a kid. I can't remember what age I was when I first read it, but I do know that I read enough times that the book looks like it was run over by a truck. Never once did I think to myself that the book was over my head or innapropriate (kids never do). I admit that when I thought back on the book I only remembered the very basic points of the book. "Young girl runs away and lives with wolves". In reading it again recently I remembered why I liked it- the wolves. I love wolves. I still do- I travel to Yellowstone as often as I can and I find myself completely enthralled when watching packs of wolves. I thought the way Julie lived with them was magical, the way they communicated and built relationships was what really held my attention as a kid.
As an adult I appreciate the rest of the story more. There is the scene between Julie and Daniel, which has been construed as rape, but which I still don't read that way. Bordering on abuse? Sure. It's enough to propel Julie out that door and into the unknown. These things happen every day. People get into fights, women (and men) are abused at the hand of their significant other, and people are raped. Just because it makes some people uncomfortable to read about it, doesn't mean it should be written about. Someone might need to read to find comfort in their own lives. However, that's not what this book is about (in my opinion). The fear she feels when she looks at Daniel is what prompts her to begin her journey on the tundra, where she really figures out who she is and what she wants. That's what the story is about, and it's a shame that some people will miss out because of one scene that has somehow managed to overshadow the rest of the story.
About the author: Please go check out Jean Craighead George's website. She has written some phenomenal books (My side of the Mountain being my favorite) and her website is an absolute wealth of knowledge.
Contest: don't forget to enter my Banned Book Week Giveaway, which includes a copy of Julie of the Wolves :)
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.ReplyDelete
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.Delete
I read this book in 6th grade it was really good i luved it!ReplyDelete
I am reading this book for the 2013-2014 EBOB book list!ReplyDelete
I read this book in fifth grade, and (despite what you say) actually wished I hadn't.ReplyDelete
I remember being very sad that I was the only avid reader in my family. I thought that, maybe, if my parents read, they'd have checked it out for me, instead of letting me choose whatever I wanted from the YA section...
It is soul crushingly depressing, and it made sex seem like a terrifying power-struggle.
After that first read, I only re-read the middle part, where she is becoming part of the wolf pack.
To pretend what happens between Miyax/Julie and Daniel is NOT a rape scene is sophistry on the part of the author-- it is, at the very least, a violent sexual assault, frightening enough to make Julie run away and try to cross the Tundra alone.
As a fifth grader, I assumed it was full-on rape, and it was extremely scary and disturbing.
I'd never let my own nine or ten year old child read it.